still didn’t make her leave, my confusion only grew. My sister had somehow gained the upper hand, but how? Vaughn and Selena were practically strangers. It was impossible for them to share secrets.
“What’s going on?” I asked when the air became charged with violent energy.
Selena was smiling. Vaughn was not.
“Pip,” I heard Vaughn whisper. There was a note of desperation in his tone, but my attention remained stubbornly locked on my sister. A heartbeat later, I felt his fingers gripping my chin as he forced my gaze away. The moment our eyes connected, he stole my lips. It didn’t take him long to get me back under his spell. Selena was a distant memory despite her proximity, and the longer we kissed, the deeper I fell.
I didn’t even notice when Vaughn lowered me on my back. My leg was now hooked inside of the crook of his arm, and he never stopped kissing me, even as he began to rock inside of me with gentle, shallow thrusts that made me mindless. It was perfect.
Except for one thing.
I stiffened when I felt fingers that didn’t belong to Vaughn caressing my hair.
“Her nipples,” my sister whispered. “I want you to suck them.”
Confusion and ecstasy battled one another when Vaughn broke our kiss to follow her directive. He offered me so much pleasure that I could barely remember my own name much less that we weren’t alone.
Vaughn had only begun laving my other when Selena spoke again. “My selfish little sister teased your cock for months,” she cooed as she played with my hair. “She never considered your needs. Instead, she toyed with you.” The wood from the picnic table creaked as she leaned over, and I felt Vaughn tense in my arms as he missed a beat. “I know you want to fuck her harder than that,” Selena goaded, sounding much closer now—like she was speaking directly in his ear. “Do it. Pound her little pussy until it hurts. Until she screams.”
Vaughn released my nipple, and when he turned his head toward my sister, the violence in them startled me. He wanted to hurt my sister badly. Selena didn’t so much as blink as she held his gaze.
“Do it.”
The muscle in his jaw ticked, and I could tell he wanted to refuse. Feeling like everything was already screwed up, I decided to make the best of this night before it took a turn for the worst.
“Hey.” This time it was me forcing his gaze away from Selena, and when he finally looked in my eyes, the turmoil in his own nearly crippled me. “There’s no one else here,” I whispered to him. I didn’t care if Selena heard me or not but judging by her snort, I knew she had. “It’s just you and me.” After a moment of hesitation, he kissed me, soft and sweet like he knew I needed. Turning my lips toward his ear opposite Selena, I gave him an order of my own. “I want you to fuck me as hard as you can, but only because it’s what I want.”
Lying on my back once more, I watched a wicked grin slowly spread his swollen lips. “Is that, right?” he drawled.
“Yes.”
Leaning down, he whispered against my lips. “You want to scream for me?”
“Hell, yes.”
He kissed me again, harder this time, before pulling out of me. This time when he filled me, he drove into me so hard my jaw actually dropped from shock as my back bowed. Unrelenting, he slammed into me again before I could even catch my breath.
And then he did it a third time.
By the fourth or fifth shove of his cock, I was convinced I’d spoken too soon. Vaughn Rees was a little more than I could handle. Somehow, it still wasn’t enough.
For a while, there was no sound but the crickets and the slap of Vaughn’s skin against mine as he fucked the shit out of me. Selena reminded me that she was there when I felt her brush my wild hair from my forehead. The feelings that Vaughn invoked were so intense that for a moment, I was almost grateful that she was there. Almost.
“Where are you going?” he demanded through gritted teeth. My body had begun scooting up the table from the force of Vaughn’s hips slamming into me. I hadn’t even realized that I was running away from him. Not missing a beat, he yanked me back down to the edge of the table and began peppering my shoulder with