here. I can still count the eight crescent-shaped marks on both my palms. These sessions have been getting easier, appointment by appointment, but I still feel sick when I remember I have a visit coming up.
“Ben?”
I finally look up, lost in the zigzag pattern of Dr. Taylor’s black-and-white blouse. “Yeah? Sorry, it was fine.”
“Anything in particular happen?”
“Not really.” There were the theme days, and the pep rally, which everyone is forced to go to. “It was Spirit Week at school.”
“Oh, those are fun. Does North Wake do the dress-up days?”
“Yeah, but I didn’t really do any. Not my kind of thing.”
“Understandable. My class used to go all out for those kinds of things.” Dr. Taylor chuckles. “I never really understood the appeal myself, but everyone seemed to have fun.”
“Hmmm.” I really don’t know what to say next.
“How are things going with Hannah and Thomas?”
I shrug. “Fine. Can’t really complain.”
“They’re getting better about the pronouns?”
I nod. I can’t really remember the last time I had to correct either of them.
“I wanted to ask you”—she crosses her legs—“how you felt when Hannah left?”
I really don’t want to answer her. I want to move on to a different question, maybe ignore what she just asked me. I know the answer. I’ve known it for ten years, but now it just makes me feel guilty. Do I really have a right to be mad at her, to still be angry at what she did, after everything?
“I …”
“Ben?” Dr. Taylor eyes me.
“I was really mad at her,” I say.
“For leaving you?”
I can’t help but feel like this will somehow all get back to Hannah. Like there’s a bug on my clothes or something and Hannah can hear every word I say from her spot in the waiting room. Just feet away. “That’s pretty much what she did, right?”
“Well …” Dr. Taylor’s head sort of bounces. “Is that what you felt happened?”
“Maybe you should ask Hannah about all this.” I don’t mean for it to sound rude, but I really don’t want to talk about this.
“Ben, I can promise you that I don’t discuss anything that goes on in this room with her.”
“Sorry.” I dig my nails into my palms again, trying to fit them in the same exact places. “I … I get why she did it,” I say, guilt washing over me. “And I get that she really couldn’t take me with her. But it still hurt, you know?”
“Of course.” Dr. Taylor jots something down. “Perhaps it is unreasonable for a college student to take on the responsibility of adopting their younger sibling, but that doesn’t invalidate the hurt caused. How do you feel about her now?”
“She’s trying.” I stare down at my hands. “And isn’t that what matters?”
“Does that matter to you?”
I nod.
“Can you tell me about a good moment you shared with your parents?” Dr. Taylor says, basically out of nowhere.
“Why?” I ask.
“Well, a lot of our discussions on them have focused on the negative, with reason, of course. But surely you had to have good moments with them, over the years?”
“I mean … yeah, kind of.” I rub my palms on my knees. Of course we had good moments. There were a lot of them actually. Moments where I could forget just how bad they could be. Where we could laugh at something on TV, or joke around with one another, or spend the day out and about, just enjoying one another’s company.
Times where I actually thought they might love me for me.
“Tell me about a good moment you had,” she says. “Doesn’t have to be anything big or anything. Just a nice thing you remember.” Dr. Taylor smiles.
“Well, it isn’t really just one specific memory,” I say. “But my mom works at a hospital, and during a lot of my summers I’d have to go with her to work. I guess she didn’t trust me to be alone with Hannah.”
“Afraid of Hannah’s influence, I’d imagine.”
I manage a chuckle. “Probably. But Mom would let me help out. She mostly did paperwork, so she taught me where things go and how to make sure they were in the right order.” I feel a smile creep up on me. “She even let me shred stuff. That was my favorite part.”
And then everything sort of stops, and for a split second, I feel numb.
“Ben?” Dr. Taylor looks at me.
“It’s nothing.”
Except the tug I feel on my heart.
The Friday nights we’d go out to dinner, Dad watching his terrible old Western movies way too loud