supposed to reproduce? That’s why Maris was so skittish around you on Oak Island. You were wondering about that, weren’t you? She doesn’t know what to make of merman offspring. She thinks you’re a freak of nature or something.”
“That’s a bit ironic, don’t you think?”
“To you, maybe.”
I laced my fingers through his. “Do you think I’m a freak of nature?”
“Absolutely. Just my type.”
Your type, I thought. Is that the best you can do? “Remember when you busted me for eavesdropping?”
“Vividly.”
“I heard my dad ask you … about how you felt about me?” I should be thoroughly flogged. Why am I doing this? Just shut up, Lily. Shut up before it’s too late. “I never heard your answer.”
Calder turned the key and cut the engine. The silence was startling.
“You know how I feel about you,” he said. I couldn’t help but notice the strange tightness in his eyes. “I’ve made no secret about it.”
“You need me,” I said.
“Yes.”
“People need lots of things.”
The corners of his mouth flinched upward, but if it was supposed to be a smile it was barely perceptible. “What do you want me to say, Lily?”
Say that you love me. Before I do. Say it out loud. “It doesn’t matter what I want you to say. It matters what you want to say.”
“This isn’t exactly the right moment,” he said.
“We’re about to go looking for a potentially killer water spirit. There might not be any other moments.”
I didn’t see where he pulled it from, but Calder rolled the dagger handle around in his palm. “Your dad wanted to know my intentions. But what I want doesn’t matter in the end.”
“The end of what?”
“Summer.” Calder motored our boat slowly across the water now. It barely felt like we were moving. “When fall comes—assuming we’re both still alive—I’ll need to look for warmer waters. It’ll be time for you to start college.”
“I don’t need college if I’m going to be a poet. All I need is inspiration.”
“Don’t you think you’re being a little naive?”
“Wherever you go when summer’s over, I’m going with you,” I said, my voice raising an octave.
“You are?” Then his face fell. “I can’t have you do that.”
“Why? Would I cramp your style in the Bahamas?”
He scowled at me. “This isn’t a joke.”
“No,” I said. “It’s not. I love you, Calder. And I want to hear you say you love me, too.”
“It’s just a word, Lily.”
“So you’re telling me you can’t say it.”
He shifted his shoulders and fidgeted nervously with the nautical charts, folding them messily and storing them away. “I’ve said it. Once, when you were asleep. Just to see how it sounded.
“Thing is, Lily, I never thought love was possible. Not for me. Not for my kind. Then you came along and changed that. I have allowed myself to love you—” He broke off and looked at me, his eyes full of pain. Then he sighed in exasperation. At me? At himself?
“Please understand,” he said. “It feels too dangerous. When I look back on my life, I’ve lost everyone I’ve ever loved. I can’t lose you, too.
“Not saying the word out loud … not admitting it to the universe, maybe it’s stupid, but this is my way of keeping you safe.”
“I appreciate the sentiment, but—”
“I can’t think about this now, Lily. We’re here. This is the spot Dr. Coyote marked. It’s time to go in.”
His words caught me unprepared, and I looked around nervously. Dr. Coyote’s approximation of Maighdean Mara’s whereabouts seemed more likely to be accurate than the Cornucopia boys’, but did that also mean she wasn’t the monster they thought she was?
Dr. Coyote had called her a benefactor. I didn’t like the idea of attacking something that had taken such care of human beings. But then again, if she had turned on us, if she was now a killer … Once more, I hoped the dagger was sufficiently sharp.
Calder busied himself with the anchor, then found some tiebacks to strap the dagger to his arm. He looked at me with purpose and put both hands on my shoulders. “Ready, then?” he asked.
Those two words imbued me with confidence. He was not going to argue with me about staying behind. We would do this together. I put one foot up on the rail and, keeping my eyes on his face, stepped up and over the side of the boat.
I sliced through the water, feeling everything rush upward—my blood to my ears, my hair trailing. I don’t know how deep I plummeted. The water here