girlfriend count?”
“Sure.”
“Then yeah.” My right shoulder bounced with my answer. “I think Andy still has feelings for you.” I was all over the place, switching from one thing to another, although everything was all related.
“Maybe,” she answered quickly. Too quickly.
“Wow. You’re not even gonna try and tell me I’m crazy?” My laugh died on my lips when she appeared tentative to continue talking about her ex.
“Why would I lie to you?”
“You shouldn’t.”
“I’m not.” Her fingers worked at the buttons of my shirt, undoing each with slow and calculated measures, gliding the tips of her nails over my skin. “But feelings might be a stretch. She’s still attracted to me, but I doubt she’s still in love with me.”
“Are you trying to distract me?” I pulled her closer and shifted my hips beneath her.
“No.”
“Getting back to Andy, is—”
“I don’t wanna talk about Andy anymore. Yes, she still desires me. In fact, before you walked up on us in the hallway at the restaurant, she asked if you and I would be interested in a threesome with her. She commented on the way I kept looking at you and she knows I won’t fuck around with her behind your back.” Now it was her turn to shrug. “It’s her way of getting to be with me again.”
So much for not talking about her anymore.
“What did you tell her?”
Again, she paused, and I wasn’t sure what to think. “I told her I didn’t think you’d be down for something like that.” I opened my mouth to respond, but she cut me off. “I know I should’ve told her no, but by putting it on you… I don’t know. I thought it was the better choice.” I must’ve unknowingly made some sort of expression because she leaned back and narrowed her eyes. “Have you ever had a threesome?”
“A few,” I answered honestly. “But never with anyone I truly cared about.” I pinned her with my gaze. “Have you?” She nodded. “With Andy?” She nodded again. “Have you had a threesome with two guys?” That time she shook her head, and it was then I remembered she’d told me she’d only ever been with two other guys, the rest being women. And unless those two slept with her at the same time, I had the answer before I asked that question.
“Have you?”
“Have I what? Had a threesome with two other guys?”
She playfully slapped my chest. “No, have you had one with a woman and another guy?”
“No.” I shook my head vigorously. “No other guys were ever allowed.”
“That might be hot, though,” she teased, pinching my nipple, and making me flinch. How the hell had our conversation gone from her being timid about telling me she’s bisexual to her telling me it’d be hot for me to be involved with a threesome, where one of the other participants was a man?
“Not gonna happen.” Once she unbuttoned my shirt, she separated the fabric, running her palm between my pecs, then lower, stopping at the waistband of my pants.
“What if I said pretty please?” She unbuckled my belt and pulled the leather strap through the loops, drawing the zipper through its teeth.
“Still no.” Then it dawned on me that I didn’t know if she was asking me to fuck another guy or for her to fuck me and another guy. “Wait, are you asking because you want to be with two guys at the same time?” I didn’t know how I’d feel if she answered yes because I wouldn’t be able to give that to her. I’d never allow another man to touch her, kiss her, stick his cock inside her.
“No, I was thinking it might be hot to see you dominate another man.”
“You can keep imagining that because it’ll never happen. Not for me. Now, if you’re talking about you and another woman, I might be down for that.” A smile spread over my face at her widened eyes, the way she licked her lips telling me the image just might have hit the target.
“Really?”
“Possibly.”
She slipped her hand into my boxer briefs and gripped me, the force of her touch making me gasp. “Then let me ask you this. Are you attracted to Andy?” Zoe shifted back on my lap so she had more room to torment me, running her thumb over the drop of precum.
“I can’t think about the answer while you’re doin’ that.”
With her hand down my pants, she leaned into me and whispered in my ear. “If you want to have a three-way with