across the back with a dozen stools. And like Eastside Eats, it’s totally and completely unfamiliar to me.
Maybe it would make sense to spend a little time at one of these places and give my memory a chance to adjust. The restaurant is clearly open for dinner already—I spot a man sitting solo at a table—so I enter the hushed interior.
A waitress looks up and smiles. She’s got short black hair, shaved along the sides, and a small silver hoop in her nose.
“I’m sorry, we don’t serve dinner until five thirty,” she says.
I glance over at the man sitting at the table and realize it’s actually a member of the waitstaff, folding black napkins.
She must read distress on my face because she adds, “We’re fully booked tonight, but there should be a seat at the bar if you want to come back right at five thirty. As you know, we serve a full menu there.”
So she remembers me.
“Yes, that’s right,” I say, accepting the card. “I loved the food. It’s . . . it’s a nice place to come on your own.”
“Isn’t it?” she says. “Feel free to bring a friend next time.”
I was alone, then, on Wednesday.
I exit and walk as fast as I can toward First Avenue, sweating in my coat, and flag down a cab headed uptown. I check my phone for the zillionth time, even though I’ve had the volume on max and would have heard a text or call from Mulroney come through. Nothing.
I place yet another call to him and this time the recording says, “The user’s mailbox is full. Please try again later.”
That makes no sense. An active private investigator would expect plenty of incoming calls and would keep his voice mail cleared to accept them. And even if he was crushed with work, he would at least respond to a paying client with a text.
What if this has all been a scam? And he provided a minimum amount of info simply to keep me happy? What if the blood-type results aren’t even true? Maybe he never really had the tissues tested.
That’d be rich, wouldn’t it? Personal finance “expert” falls prey to con artist.
But he can’t be a fraud. He’s a former New York City detective, and my gut told me that he was the real thing.
I rack my brain, turning up the few things I know about him. He mentioned that he lived on West Ninety-Seventh Street. And when we were at the diner, he admitted that he liked to drop by there in the early evenings and mull over his cases.
“Let me off at Ninety-Ninth and Broadway instead,” I call to the driver through the plexiglass barrier.
By the time we finally pull up at Broadway Diner, it’s growing dark outside and I’m ready to crawl out of my skin. I quickly pay the fare and charge across the sidewalk to the restaurant.
I pause once I’m inside, raking my gaze over the counter, as well as every table and booth. There’s no sign of Mulroney. I turn and retreat outside.
Standing on the sidewalk, I feel the oddest urge to cry. Not because I’ve possibly lost a thousand bucks or fallen prey to a scam. But because my quest to know the truth seems hopelessly stunted, and some of what I’ve learned so far might not even be true.
But surely, I chide myself, I’m overreacting. It’s only been eight hours since I first tried Mulroney and he might be doing a surveillance job that demands every ounce of his attention.
Except he said he would be on his cell.
I hurry the two blocks to Ninety-Seventh Street and wander between Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue. Hours ago, I was scared to be on the street alone, and now here I am casing an unfamiliar block at dusk. When I don’t have any luck, I try the other side of Broadway next, swiveling my head as I walk to West End Avenue and then toward Riverside Drive. It’s more deserted in this area, and a couple of times I turn to look behind me.
There’s no sign of Mulroney here either. Did I honestly think I’d simply bump into him as he was headed home?
I try him one more time and hear the same message about the mailbox being full. If he’s ridiculously tied up, why not have his partner cover for him?
His partner. He must have a phone as well. As I reverse course and hurry back toward Broadway, I pull up the company website and see