was no primary motive, at least not for Arty. Jim was often guilty of indulging more often than necessary with their female captives, but Arty understood and forgave him for that, it was just his younger brother’s way.
Their primary motive for what they did was summed up best by Arty years back when a previous female captive asked the all-too common question:
“Why are you doing this to me?”
Arty had thought hard for several moments after the question; he was searching for something clever that would define it all with swift decisiveness. And when the perfect response had finally hit him all at once, and his eyes had settled contently with an odd mix of pride and foreboding, he leaned in close to the female captive and did not give an answer, but instead asked a question.
“When you see someone trip and fall, what do you do?”
The female captive had looked at Arty through swollen red eyes that were still capable of projecting confusion.
“I’ll ask again. When you watch someone slip, trip, or fall in everyday life, what do you often do?”
When the answer had appeared on the woman’s face, it was obvious. Those swollen red eyes had discarded confusion in order to project shame. Arty wondered if she would tell the truth.
“I guess I sometimes laugh,” the woman admitted, looking away.
Arty had been pleased with her honesty; it allowed him to continue with his perfect response.
“Thank you for being honest. We laugh too. We just raise the bar a little in order to keep laughing.” Arty then stood, smiled, and added, “I hope that helps you understand. And I hope I don’t disappoint when I say…it really is as simple as that.”
9
Amy still wasn’t wild about the newly polished terrier, but Lorraine had assured her the dog was safe, and had actually been coined the unofficial mascot of Crescent Lake this past year.
“So he just showed up one day?” Amy asked Lorraine. “Out of the blue?”
“Yup. I was out tending to some things in the garden when I heard this pathetic little whimper. The poor thing looked as though it hadn’t eaten in weeks. I stuffed his belly and we haven’t been able to get rid of him since.”
“And people here don’t mind?” Patrick asked.
“Some do,” Norman Mitchell replied. “But he’s a clever bugger. He knows who to go pouting to—and it looks as if he’s found a winner in your Carrie.”
“Wonderful,” Patrick and Amy said simultaneously.
The four adults sat around a large wooden table on the back porch of the Mitchell’s cabin. It was past five and dusk was just starting to gray the light. The grill was fired-up and leaking smoke out of both corners, filling the air with the heavenly aroma of all things char-grilled.
Carrie and Caleb ran and giggled further back in the yard as the terrier yapped and darted at their heels, both siblings completely oblivious to everything else in life except the newfound joy that was fifteen furry pounds of endless entertainment.
“I don’t know who’s got more energy, that mutt or your kids,” Norman said. Norman Mitchell was a short, squat man with a cherub face that said friendly no matter which way you looked at it. His black hair was gone save for the long strip that wrapped around the back of his head from ear to ear. Patrick had told Amy a few years back that he was the spitting image of a slightly taller Danny Devito and she had instantly agreed.
“I’m putting my money on Carrie,” Patrick said. “Caleb will poop out soon. He’s like his old man—prefers to kick back and relax and watch others do the work. Now Carrie on the other hand, she’s my lovely wife’s child. She—”
Amy reached over and gripped her husband’s ear. “Yes, honey? Please go on.”
Patrick gave an exaggerated wince of agony. “You see this?” he said, pointing to the ear still in Amy’s clutches. “This happens all the time. Spousal abuse.”
Amy let go and pushed his head away. “Oh boo hoo, you big sissy.”
Patrick pointed at his wife again. “Psychological abuse too. I’m a broken man inside.”
“You’re my bitch. Accept it,” Amy said.
Both Mitchells laughed. Patrick shook his head in defeat, finished his beer, and raised the empty bottle. “I think I may need a refill here, Norm. Gotta ease the pain on my wounded ear and shattered ego.”
Norman smiled at the couple and headed towards the back door leading into the kitchen, grilling spatula still in hand. He stopped in the doorway