be ready in five.”
He disappeared into the bedroom area while I finished getting ready at the mirror. When my hair was neat enough and my makeup complete, I turned off the light.
“Well?” I said, presenting myself to Cole, who was dressed in a charcoal suit with a light blue dress shirt. His hair was combed, his shoes were shined, and the room smelled like his cologne. As always, he set off butterflies in my stomach. “How do I look?” I asked.
He looked up from adjusting a cufflink. “Hmm.”
“Hmm?” I stuck my hands on my hips and pouted. “That’s not the right answer.”
“I know, but . . .” He studied me as he came closer.
“What?” I looked down at the chunky, off-the-shoulder sweater dress. “I thought you’d like this outfit. It’s the same one I wore on—”
“I know. I do like it.” He circled me like I was a bride trying on a wedding gown and he was the dude from Say Yes to the Dress. “It’s just missing something.”
“It is?” I touched my earlobes. “Oh, I forgot my earrings!”
“No. That’s not what’s missing.” He moved around to the front of me again, reached into his pocket and took out a small box. Then he opened it. “This is.”
I couldn’t breathe. Twinkling against the black velvet cushion inside the box was a gorgeous diamond solitaire on a delicate silver band.
Cole got down on one knee. “This was supposed to happen at dinner,” he said. “But I just can’t wait another minute.”
I covered my mouth with both hands and squeaked.
“Cheyenne Dempsey, I’ve known you almost my entire life. And even though our paths took us in different directions for a while, I know in my heart that right now, I’m exactly where I’m supposed to be. I’m with the woman I want to spend the rest of my life with. And when I think about our future together, I’m happier than I ever imagined was possible.”
I started to cry and had to wipe tears from beneath my eyes.
He smiled, although his eyes shone too. “Now I don’t come alone,” he said. “Mariah and I are sort of a package deal.”
Laughing, I sniffed and nodded.
“But she and I agree that you make our family complete—for now, at least. Hopefully we’ll continue to grow it in the years to come.” He plucked the solitaire from the box and took my left hand, slipping it onto my ring finger. “I love you more than I could ever say.” His smile turned boyish and a little crooked. “And as someone once told me, when you have something precious in your hands, you need to hold on tight. Tonight, I’m asking to hold onto you forever. Will you marry me?”
“Yes,” I bawled, tears spilling down my face. “Yes, yes, yes!”
He rose to his feet and kissed me quickly before embracing me, lifting me right off my feet. I wrapped my arms around his neck and held on tight, just like he said.
After I’d blubbered into his shoulder for a minute or two, he set me on my feet and I finally looked at the ring on my finger. “I can’t believe it!” I said, laughing and crying at the same time. “Is it real?”
“It’s real.”
I whirled around, expecting people to jump out of the closet. “Where’s Mariah? Are Griffin and Blair here? Our mothers?”
“No,” he said. “I thought about it, but decided this was something I wanted to do without an audience.”
“I get it.” I couldn’t take my eyes off my ring—my engagement ring! “But do they know?”
“They know,” he admitted. “And I promised Mariah we’d call her as soon as it happened.”
“Oh, let’s call her really quick!” I grabbed my phone. “I know it’s almost nine, but I need to show this ring off or I’m going to burst!”
He laughed. “Okay, I also need to change my shirt.”
I winced, looking at the wet splotch, which also had black mascara smudges. “Sorry.”
“It’s okay. I have another.”
“I bet my face looks like that too, huh?”
He didn’t bother lying. “A bit.”
I took thirty seconds to repair my mascara and eyeliner and then sat on the bed to FaceTime Cole’s mom.
She and Mariah appeared on the screen. “Hello?” His mother said.
“Did he do it?” Mariah shrieked.
I held up my left hand. “He did it!”
“Yay!” They both cheered, and Mrs. Mitchell wiped her eyes. “I’m so happy,” she said.
“Me too,” chirped Mariah. “Daddy said I can be in the wedding!”
“Well, of course you can,” I said. “You have to be my