minutes to confer with Alvin before the arraignment began, and always with the sheriff present, so there couldn't be much candor - but such was the rule with witch trials, so no potions or powders could be passed between them, or secret curses spoken. "No matter how it seems, Alvin, you must trust me."
"Why? How is it going to seem?"
"The judge is John Adams. I've been reading his writings and his court cases, both as lawyer and as judge, since I first began the study of law. The man is decent to the core. I had no knowledge of his ever doing a witch trial, though, and so I had no idea of his position on them. But when I came out of jail this morning, I was met by a fellow who lives here - "
"No need for names," said Alvin.
Verily smiled. "A fellow, I say, who's made some study of witch law - in fact that's his name, Study - and he tells me that Adams has never actually rendered a verdict in a witchery case."
"What does that mean?"
"There's always been some defect in the witchers' presentation and he's thrown the whole thing out."
"Then that's good," said Alvin.
"No," said Verily. "That's bad."
"I'd go free, wouldn't l?"
"But the law would still stand."
Alvin rolled his eyes. "Verily, I didn't come back here to try to reform New England, I came in order to - "
"We came to help Purity," said Verily. "And all the others. Do you know what it would mean, if the law itself were found defective? Adams is a man of weighty reputation. Even from the circuit bench of Boston, his decisions would be looked at carefully and carry much precedence in England as well as in America. The right decision might mean the end of witch trials, here as well as there."
Alvin smiled thinly. "You got too high an opinion of human nature."
"Do I?"
"The law didn't make witch trials happen. It was the hunger for witch trials that got them to make up the law."
"But if we do away with the legal basis - "
"Listen, Verily, do you think men like Quill will flat-out disappear just cause witchery ain't there to give them what they want? No, they'll just find another way to do the same job."
"You don't know that."
"If it ain't witchcraft, they'll find new crimes that work just the way witchcraft does, so you can take ordinary folks making ordinary mistakes or not even mistakes, just going about their business, but suddenly the witcher, he finds some wickedness in it, and turns everything they say into proof that they're guilty of causing every bad thing that's been going wrong."
"There's no other law that works that way."
"That's because we got witch laws, Very. Get rid of them, and people will find a way take all the sins of the world and put them onto the heads of some fellow who's attracted their attention and then destroy him and all his friends."
"Purity isn't evil, Alvin."
"Quill is," said Alvin.
The sheriff leaned down. "I'm trying not to listen, boys, but you know it's a crime to speak ill of a witcher. This Quill, he takes it as evidence that Satan's got you by the short hairs, begging your pardon."
"Thank you for the reminder, sir," said Verily. "My client didn't mean it quite the way it sounded."
The sheriff rolled his eyes. "From what I've seen, it doesn't matter much how it sounds when you say it. What matters is how it sounds when Quill repeats it."
Verily grinned at the sheriff and then at Alvin.
"What are you smiling at?" asked Alvin.
"I just got all the proof I need that you're wrong. People don't like the way the witch trials work. People don't like injustice. Strike down these laws and no one will miss them."
Alvin shook his head. "Good people won't miss them. But it wasn't good people as set them up in the first place. It was scared people. The world ain't steady. Bad things happen even when you been careful and done no wrong. Good people, strong people, they take that in stride, but them as is scared and weak, they want somebody to blame. The good people will think they've stamped out witch trials, but the next generation they'll turn around and there they'll be again, wearing a different hat, going by a different name, but witch trials all the same, where they care more about getting somebody punished than whether they're actually guilty of