for? Why on earth would one of the servants kill Thaddeus?"
Hester's mind raced. "Perhaps he caught them stealing?"
"Stealing what - on the first landing? He fell off the balcony of the first landing. The servants would all be downstairs at that time in the evening, except maybe a ladies' maid."
"Jewelry?"
"How would he know they had been stealing? If they were in a bedroom he wouldn't know it. And if he saw them coming out, he would only presume they were about their duties."
That was totally logical. Hester had no argument. She searched her mind and could think of nothing comforting to say.
"What about the doctor?" she tried.
Edith flashed a weak smile at her, appreciating what she was attempting.
"Dr. Hargrave? I don't know if it's possible. Damaris did tell me what happened that evening, but she didn't seem very clear. In feet she was pretty devastated, and hardly coherent at all."
"Well, where were they?" Hester had already been involved in two murders, the first because of the deaths of her own parents, the second through her acquaintance with the policeman William Monk, who was now working privately for anyone who required relatives traced, thefts solved discreetly, and other such matters dealt with in a private capacity, where they preferred not to engage the law or where no crime had been committed. Surely if she used her intelligence and a little logic she ought to be of some assistance.
"Since they assumed at first that it was an accident," she said aloud, "surely he must have been alone. Where was everyone else? At a dinner party people are not wandering around the house individually."
"That's just it," Edith said with increasing unhappiness. "Damaris made hardly any sense. I've never seen her so. . . so completely . . . out of control. Even Peverell couldn't calm or comfort her - she would scarcely speak to him."
"Perhaps they had a . . ." Hester sought for some polite way of phrasing it. "Some difference of opinion? A misunderstanding?"
Edith's mouth twitched with amusement. "How euphemistic of you. You mean a quarrel? I doubt it. Peverell really isn't that kind of person. He is rather sweet, and very fond of her." She swallowed, and smiled with a sudden edge of sadness, as of other things briefly remembered, perhaps other people. "He isn't weak at all," she went on. "I used to think he was. But he just has a way of dealing with her, and she usually comes 'round - in the end. Really much more satisfactory than ordering people. I admit he may not be an instant great passion, but I like him. In fact, the longer I know him the more I like him. And I rather think she feels the same." She shook her head minutely. "No, I remember the way she was when she came home that evening. I don't think Peverell had anything to do with it."
"What did she say about where people were? Thaddeus - I beg your pardon, General Carlyon - fell, or was pushed, over the banister from the first landing. Where was everyone else at the time?"
"Coming and going," Edith said hopelessly. "I haven't managed to make any sense of it. Perhaps you can. I asked Damaris to come and join us, if she remembers. But she doesn't seem to know what she's doing since that evening."
Hester had not met Edith's sister, but she had heard frequent reference to her, and it seemed that either she was emotionally volatile and somewhat undisciplined or she had been judged unkindly.
At that moment, as if to prove her a bar, the door opened and one of the most striking women Hester had ever seen stood framed by the lintel. For that first moment she seemed heroically beautiful, tall, even taller than Hester or Edith, and very lean. Her hair was dark and soft with natural curl, unlike the present severe style in which a woman's hair was worn scraped back from the face with ringlets over the ears, and she seemed to have no regard for fashion. Indeed her skirt was serviceable, designed for work, without the crinoline hoops, and yet her blouse was gorgeously embroidered and woven with white ribbon. She had a boyish air about her, neither coquettish nor demure, simply blazingly candid. Her face was long, her features so mobile and sensitive they reflected her every thought.
She came in and closed the door, leaning against it for a moment with both hands behind her and regarding Hester with