He began fucking me, and I finally understood what he meant. He claimed me like an animal with hard thrusts of his hips and animalistic grunts of pleasure. He shifted my leg, slamming even deeper into me. My ass rubbed over the hard stone. I’d be sore tomorrow, inside and outside.
One of his hands cupped my breast, kneading, pinching, pulling. His eyes held mine during every thrust. Sweat glistened on his muscled chest and his muscled, hairy thighs rubbed against the sensitive inside of my thighs as he slammed into me.
Spears of pleasure burst through the fog of pain, brighter with every second that passed. I dug my nails into his shoulders. Laughter burst through my bubble.
“They can’t see us,” Dark promised as he kissed my ear. “It’s only us. Only my cock claiming that tight pussy.”
He pulled out suddenly and hoisted me off the banister. “Turn around and brace yourself against the rail.”
I did as he asked. My fingers curled over the cold stone and I bent forward, extending my butt for him. He stroked my ass cheeks. “Our night will leave marks.”
“In more than one way,” I said, not even sure why.
His cock parted me and slid into me. I winced. In this position he seemed to go even deeper, claiming more of me than before. My fingers on the stone tightened as he began thrusting again. His hands stroked my back then one of them slid down between my legs, finding my clit. His other hand cupped my breast. Overwhelmed by sensations, I closed my eyes against the beautiful sight before me, losing myself in pleasure. “Come for me, Jean.” His voice ghosted over my ear.
My body clenched, my head falling forward and I gasped out. Clenching around him, a potent mix of pleasure and pain exploded in my body, making stars dance before my eyes. Part of me wanted to pull away from the pain, the other wanted his cock even deeper to savor the pleasure.
Dark fucked me even harder. I had trouble keeping my balance, my body still shaken by my orgasm, but he didn’t show any mercy. He gripped my hips, pulling me against him as he slammed into me, spearing me on his cock.
I gasped again, sore and turned on, exhausted and exhilarated.
With a groan and a shudder, he came, his cock expanding. My eyes still shut, I breathed deeply, feeling connected to this stranger like I’d never felt to someone before. Maybe sex without emotion was a hoax after all. Not that it mattered.
“I’ve been thinking about this moment for days.”
I frowned, my eyes fluttering open. He rubbed my back and kissed my shoulder. “I always get what I want, Jean, even your firsts.”
4
Dark pulled out of me, and I turned quickly. My lips fell open as I stared up at Mr. Chanler’s smiling face. He’d shaved off his beard and taken off the mask that had fooled me.
He nodded, stroking his now-smooth chin. “I shaved it to trick you. But I should tell you, you missed out. A beard, if used the right way, adds to your pleasure during oral.”
I blinked, frozen by shock. “You tricked me?”
He leaned closer. He smelled of sex, of me…of us.
“I tried to give you a little push while you considered my offer. Admit it, I was convincing, wasn’t I?”
He reached for my mask as if he was going to take it off like his, but I swatted his hand away and shoved past him. My emotions tumbled over each other. I wasn’t sure what I felt; anger was the easiest choice. I picked up my clothes from the floor, not sparing Mr. Chanler a single glance.
“Don’t leave yet. We still have all night to enjoy each other.”
“You…you…bastard!” I stormed into the bathroom, my clothes clutched against my naked chest.
Turning the lights on, I leaned against the door and stared at myself in the wide mirror. I looked frazzled, as if I’d been thoroughly fucked, and that was the case. The feathers in my mask were twisted, some even broken, almost all of them in disarray.
My thighs were sticky, and I was sore. I twisted until I could see my red ass in the mirror. My face soon turned the same color. I’d sworn to give my firsts to someone else, anyone but Mr. Chanler, but it was difficult to regret the events of the night when my body still tingled from my orgasms.