"I don't know," he said, his gaze first on me, then on Alec. "But I'm happy for Alec nonetheless. One way or another, it would appear he has a Beloved again."
My gaze shifted back to Alec, as well. His expression was impossible to read, his eyes burning with a light . . . but what sort of a light?
"This is ridiculous, nothing but a tissue of lies," Eleanor said, marching over to clutch Alec. "And I resent the fact that any of you could be so foolish as to believe any of it. I was his Beloved, not her. You summoned me back from death. She is nothing to us, nothing!"
"I'm sorry," I told Alec, ignoring Eleanor's ranting.
"For what?" he asked.
I made a wordless gesture of confusion. "For . . . for making things more complicated."
"'Complicated' is an understatement. I just don't understand how you can both be here if you're really . . . what, the same person?" Pia asked.
"We can't. That is proof that she is the false one," Eleanor said, trying to force Alec to look at her. "Feed from me, my darling. Then you will know the truth."
To my dismay, Alec turned his attention on her, looking very much like he was going to accept her offer and feed. He gazed into her face, his eyes glittering jade. "You have no soul," he said finally.
She jerked back out of his grip, her own eyes blazing with fury as she jabbed a finger toward Kristoff and Pia. "That is not my fault! It is because they had me brought back as a lich!"
"Liches have souls," Kristoff said slowly as we all looked at Eleanor. "They get them back when they are raised by a necromancer."
"Then the necromancer who you hired to raise me did it incorrectly," Eleanor snapped.
Alec looked at me with speculation. "Kris, what do you know about reincarnation?"
"Not a lot," he said with a shrug, then raised his eyebrows. "I've heard that only a certain type of mortal can be reincarnated, that the mortal being dies, is judged on their purity of heart, and accordingly granted life again based on that purity. Oh, you mean - "
"Yes," Alec said, his sudden smile so brilliant, it made me clutch the couch to keep from flinging myself on him. "I think Cora is one of those beings. She was born as Eleanor, was killed, and reincarnated into her current form, soul and all."
I stared at him, caught in the green snare of his gaze, wanting to believe the joy he felt was due to the fact that there might be a future for us rather than I was merely a form of salvation.
"That would explain why Eleanor doesn't have a soul?" Pia asked.
"No, it wouldn't. It doesn't," Eleanor insisted. "If she and I are the same person - and really, the idea is ludicrous ; just look at her! She's completely unlike me. If we were the same person, we couldn't exist together in the same time and place."
"But you don't, not really," Kristoff said gently. "You're a lich. Your existence is beyond the mortal world. Cora is mortal. You aren't."
I dragged my gaze off Alec to look at Eleanor, wondering if I had really ever been her. What a pain in the ass I was.
Alec laughed in my head. I wouldn't say that, but I admit that I had only just met you when you were killed.
"Even admitting that was possible - and I don't admit that for one minute. But let's say it is. Then all that means is that she's a knockoff of me, and I'm the original Beloved, and she has my soul." Eleanor's eyes narrowed on me. "And she can just give it back!"
"Oh, that is not going to happen," I told her, amused despite the unpleasant situation. "Finders keepers, and all that."
"Faugh!" she yelled at me, and spent the next five minutes arguing that Alec owed his allegiance to her.
"It seems to me that you're just going to have to decide," Kristoff told Alec when Eleanor wound down long enough for someone else to get in a word. "Cora or Eleanor. Which Beloved do you want?"
Instantly, my eyes went to Alec's, my heart beating with sudden urgency.
"That is the question, isn't it?" he said softly, smiling at Eleanor. She beamed back at him until he lifted her hand and kissed it. "I can't tell you how grateful I am that you agreed to the plan to save me. You will have my eternal appreciation for such a noble act."
"No," Eleanor snarled, jerking her hand from his and backing away, her face black with rage. "You can't mean that! You can't pick her over me. I was brought back to save you!"
"I know you were, and I regret greatly - "
"Nooo!" she wailed, and bolted from the room.